Effect of vaccination programmes on mortality burden among children and young adults in the Netherlands during the 20th century: a historical analysis

Tuesday, 16th of February 2016

Effect of vaccination programmes on mortality burden among children and young adults in the Netherlands during the 20th century: a historical analysis

Maarten van Wijhe MSc  Scott A McDonald PhD  Hester E de Melker PhD  Prof Maarten J Postma PhD

 Prof Jacco Wallinga PhD

Published Online: 09 February 2016

Summary

Background

In the 20th century childhood mortality decreased rapidly and vaccination programmes are frequently suggested as a contributing factor. However quantification of this contribution is subject to debate or absent. We present historical data from the Netherlands that allow us to quantify the reduction in childhood mortality burden for vaccine-preventable diseases in this period as a function of vaccination coverage.

Methods

We retrieved cause-specific and age-specific historical mortality data from Statistics Netherlands from 1903 to 2012 (for Dutch birth cohorts born from 1903 to 1992) and data for vaccination coverage since the start of vaccination programmes from the Dutch Health Care Inspectorate and the Dutch National Institute for Public Health and the Environment. We also obtained birth and migration data from Statistics Netherlands. We used a restricted mean life-time method to estimate cause-specific mortality burden among children and young adults for each birth cohort as the years of life lost up to age 20 years excluding migration as a variable because this did not affect the results. To correct for long-term trends we calculated the cause-specific contribution to the total childhood mortality burden.

Findings

In the pre vaccination era the contribution to mortality burden was fairly constant for diphtheria (1·4%) pertussis (3·8%) and tetanus (0·1%). Around the start of mass vaccinations these contributions to the mortality burden decreased rapidly to near zero. We noted similar patterns for poliomyelitis mumps and rubella. The number of deaths due to measles around the start of vaccination in the Netherlands were too few to detect an accelerated rate of decrease after mass vaccinations were started. We estimate that mass vaccination programmes averted 148 000 years of life lost up to age 20 years (95% prediction interval 110 000–201 000) among children born before 1992. This corresponds to about 9000 deaths averted (6000–12 000).

Interpretation

Our historical time series analysis of mortality and vaccination coverage shows a strong association between increasing vaccination coverage and diminishing contribution of vaccine-preventable diseases to overall mortality. This analysis provides further evidence that mass vaccination programmes contributed to lowering childhood mortality burden.

Funding

Dutch Ministry of Health Welfare and Sport.

URL http://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(16)00027-X/abstract