Wednesday, 27th of January 2016 |
FEBRUARY 20 2015
Why Debunking Myths About Vaccines Hasnt Convinced Dubious Parents
Seventeen years ago a physician in the UK published a study of twelve children who had been given the MMR (measles mumps rubella) vaccine. It implied a scary correlation between the vaccine and autism. But upon both further investigation and further clinical studies the original finding was thrown out the medical journal retracted the article and the doctor was found to have unethical financial interests in the findings. Finally he was stripped of his license to practice medicine.
Yet today surveys show that as many as a third of U.S. parents still believe the discredited allegations. One in five milliennials believe early childhood vaccines cause autism and 26% of parents trust a celebrity as a credible source on vaccine safety. And measles declared officially eradicated in the U.S. in the year 2000 is back.
This has all led to a contentious debate among parents politicians and the medical community. But as someone who does communications for a living I have a professional interest in this as well. Why it is so difficult to dispel rumors and debunk myths? I see four major reasons.
1. Arguing the facts doesnt help—in fact it makes the situation worse. In 1979 Charles Lord performed a seminal piece of research that revealed when you show someone factual scientific evidence that they are wrong they react badly. They will only accept the evidence that fits their pre-existing views. Lord called this effect “confirmation bias.” There have been hundreds of studies since all finding the same results when you argue using facts and evidence people generally reject or discount your evidence. Instead of changing their minds most will dig in their heels and cling even more firmly to their originally held views. Brendan Nyhan of Dartmouth and Jason Reifler of the University of Exeter have also documented an even more alarming tendency which they call “the backfire effect.” In their study correcting people actually increased their misperceptions.
2. Repeating the myth inadvertently popularizes it. When you repeat the myth while trying to debunk it you do two things first you introduce the myth to people who may never have heard it. As many as 40% then believe it. Second by repeating the myth you unintentionally convert “false claims into recommendations” as one study shows. They found that after three days older adults misremembered 28% of false statements as being true but once the false statements were repeated three times the number of people who confused them as being true jumped to 40%. So repeating wrong information even to debunk it backfires.
3. Affirmation works – but we rarely use it. When someone has their facts wrong our impulse is generally not to tell them we think theyre great. Were more likely to go on the attack.
But Nyhan and Reifler in their research on misperceptions and corrections discovered that when people who are mistaken undergo a self-affirmation exercise it increases the odds that theyll accept the corrected information. That means you may have more success changing minds after making your audience feel good about themselves.
Part of the polarization happening in the vaccine debate stems from the vilifying of those parents who have not vaccinated their children. Instead of going on the attack pro-vaccine advocates should reassure parents that we know they love their children. Treating them as idiots or fringe lunatics will only worsen the discussion about the science.
4. We consistently underestimate the power of narrative. In the 1940s Austrian psychologist Fritz Heider created what has become a legendary piece of research that reveals the need for people to craft narratives. Heider created a short simple animation of two triangles a rectangle and a circle. His subjects all (except one) read a complete drama into the animation complete with love affairs and bullying. Humans it seems must have a story line and in a void will create one.
In the vaccine wars the anti-vaccination movement has referenced many narratives. Each narrative is different but each one features a protagonist and a villain along with attempts to bury or distort the “facts.”
Model actress and celebrity activist Jenny McCarthy has been one of the most outspoken critics of vaccinations in the U.S. She has drawn upon a personal narrative of her son whom she claims was rendered autistic by a vaccination but later cured through organic and holistic approaches. McCarthy leverages a very powerful technique known to social scientists as the “identifiable victim effect.”
It turns out human empathy does not scale well. We can care very deeply about one single stranger but that empathy wanes rapidly as the group of victims grows. Once it becomes a large number we cease caring. By repeating her emotional story McCarthy draws upon this psycho-sociological phenomenon. And when put head-to-head with scientists talking about immunology the story of her child will sway audiences every time. When challenged on her lack of scientific proof McCarthy has retorted “Evan is my science.”
Stephan Lewandowsky a professor who researches the debunking of myths wrote “The Debunking Myth Handbook.” In it he points out that it is not good enough to knock down a myth and leave a narrative vacuum. You must create a credible alternative narrative.
Think of all the times youve tried to clarify something by saying “Its X not Y.” Or of all the times youve resorted to the facts to win an argument. Or of how tempting it is to tease or belittle someone you know is in the wrong.
We all fall into these traps. But all youre doing is reinforcing the information you dont want people to hear increasing their resistance to your message and making it harder for them to hear you in the first place.
Instead we need to dispel rumors and debunk myths without repeating the misinformation rely on a compelling proactive narrative and realize that more information is not necessarily better.
Christopher Graves is global chairman for Ogilvy Public Relations. He is also Chair of the PR Council. He is on Twitter at @cgraves.
Assessment of Immune Status Against Measles, Mum ...
Assessment of Immune Status Against Measles, Mumps, and Rubella in Young Kuwaitis: MMR Vaccine Efficacy. Madi N, Altawalah H, Alfouzan W ...2017 M&RI Partners Meeting Presentations
The global Measles and Rubella Initiative meeting was held in Washington DC on 7th and 8th Sept. 2017. The meeting which was hosted by American Red Cr ...STORIES OF LIFE IN A CHANGING WORLD Scientists Cr ...
STORIES OF LIFE IN A CHANGING WORLD Scientists Crack a 50-Year-Old Mystery about the Measles Vaccine Worth a little pain? Back in 1990 a school bo ...20 most consulted measles and rubella articles in ...
Dear AllToday we share a review of the year 2016 regarding measles and rubella items posted on our web page. We shared articles on topics ranging from ...Region of the Americas is declared free of measles ...
More information on this great milestone can be found on url link belowhttp://www.paho.org/hq/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=125 ...Progress Toward Regional Measles Elimination — W ...
Progress Toward Regional Measles Elimination — Worldwide, 2000–2014 Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report Best read, with ta ...Health Equity Initiative, New York, NY, 25-26 Febr ...
Health Equity Initiative, Summit, NYC, 25-26 February 2016 For details, consult http://www.healthequityinitiative.org/hei/programs/summit/REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL: MEASLES VACCINATION UNDER 9 ...
1 REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL: Measles Vaccination Under 9 Months of Age APPLICATION SUBMISSION DATE: January 26, 2015 1. In ...CARTOON CHARACTERS JOIN THE FIGHT AGAINST MEASLES
[source] Measles and Rubella Initiative[|source]Thanks to reader Jane Wachira for pointing out the following weblink. Measles eradication consists not ...I LOVE/HATE THIS GLOBAL VACCINATION COVERAGE GRAPH ...
[source]Rosling s FactPod[|source]This video from Hans Rosling explaining what he loves with global measles vaccination coverage trends namely rapid i ...POWER POINT PRESENTATIONS FROM THE 13TH ANNUAL ADV ...
[source]Measles and Rubella Initiative[|source]The Measles and Rubella Initiative has spent much effort fighting for its cause by means of widespread ...CALLING THE SHOTS
[source]PBS Network[|source]"VACCINES -- CALLING THE SHOTS" This TV program, broadcast on the PBS network, looks at the commonest arguments by anti-v ...COMBATING HEALTHCARE CORRUPTION AND FRAUD WITH IMP ...
[source]BMC International Health and Human Rights[|source]Corruption is a serious threat to global health outcomes, leading to financial waste and adv ...CORRUPTION KILLS: ESTIMATING THE GLOBAL IMPACT OF ...
[source]PLoS One[|source]Many countries still have high levels of child mortality, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, and in recent ye ...READY OR NOT: RESPONDING TO MEASLES IN THE POSTELI ...
[source]Annals of Internal Medicine[|source]Opnion Paper Although endemic measles was eliminated in the United States in 2000, two concurrent measle ...RUBELLA AND CONGENITAL RUBELLA SYNDROME CONTROL AN ...
[source]Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR)[|source]In 2011, the World Health Organization (WHO) updated guidance on the preferred strategy f ...PROGRESS TOWARDS MEASLES ELIMINATION – EASTERN M ...
[source]Weekly Epidemiological Record (WER)[|source]During the period 2008–2012, regional progress towards measles elimination stagnated, and th ...THE IMMUNIZATION PROGRAMME THAT SAVED MILLIONS OF ...
[source]Bulletin of the WHO[|source]In the world vaccination week, the Bulletin of the World Health Organization outlines the history, status and impa ...HEALTH SYSTEM COST OF DELIVERING ROUTINE VACCINATI ...
[source]Bulletin of the WHO[|source]On the eve of the 40th anniversary of launching of the Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) in 1974, during th ...World Immunization Week
[source]WHO/IVB Publication[|source]Never miss another jab, The slogan for World Immunization Week 2014 is “Immunize for a healthy future: Know ...Measles: know the risks, check your status, protec ...
[source]WHO/IVB Publication[|source]Measles is a highly contagious, serious disease caused by a virus. In 1980, before widespread vaccination, measles ...THE RIGHTS OF THE UNVACCINATED CHILD: THE LEGAL FR ...
[source]Los Angeles Times[|source]In light of what s starting to look like a surge of measles cases spread by unvaccinated carriers, Hasting ...Consultants: Measles and rubella control/eliminati ...
[source]Technical Network for Strengthening EPI[|source]Announcement solicits interest from potential candidates to act as consultants for WHO through ...PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS MARK 50TH YEAR OF MEASLES ...
[source]Journal of American Medical Association[|source]Until the 1960s, measles was a rite of passage for US children; nearly all had the disease bef ...THE TOLL OF THE ANTI-VACCINATION MOVEMENT, IN ONE ...
[source]Los Angelos Times[|source]Aaron Carroll today offers a graphic depiction of the toll of the anti-vaccination movement. It comes from a Council ...“Can we use $30 of the taxes you’re already pa ...
[source]Annual Letter of BMGF[|source]If you were asked this question today, what answer would you give? Bill and Melinda Gates ask, "Would you check ...REACHING HARD-TO-REACH INDIVIDUALS: NONSELECTIVE V ...
[source]American Journal of Epidemiology[|source]Source: American Journal of Epidemiology The World Health Organization guidelines for response to me ...Rubella and Congenital rubella syndrome control an ...
[source]Weekly Epidemiological Record (WER)[|source]Full text record of Rubella and CRS control/elimination are available at http://www.who.int/wer/20 ...Measles Press Conference at CDC: 50th Anniversary ...
[source]CDC Media Release, 5th Dec[|source]Full text, video and question and answer session for journalists all avalable at http://www.cdc.gov/media/r ...A bibliometric analysis of childhood immunization ...
[source]BMC Medicine[|source]During the past four decades national EPI programs have developed or adapted and implemented a broad range of strategies ...Lessons from the tragic measles outbreak in Samoa
Monday, 9th of March 2020 |
Characterisation of diversity of measles viruses in India: genomic sequencing and comparative genomics studies.
Monday, 9th of March 2020 |
The elimination of measles in Iran
Monday, 9th of March 2020 |
Measles-containing vaccines in Brazil: Coverage,
Monday, 9th of March 2020 |
Measles-containing vaccines in Brazil: Coverage, homogeneity of coverage and associations with contextual factors at municipal level.
Monday, 9th of March 2020 |
Website Views |
47324794 |